2 min read

The Performance Bar Just Moved

audio-thumbnail
The Performance Bar Just Moved (read by Dave)
0:00
/180.5

Happy Friday,

Frustrated by design deficiencies affecting construction, a contractor ran the engineer's plans and specifications through AI. The result was a comprehensive list of apparent errors, omissions, and cut-and-paste content from other projects, each accompanied by brief, understandable commentary.

The contractor presented the list to the client along with a significant change-order request. Faced with such compelling evidence, the client sued the design engineer for the resulting costs. How could they not?

Did the design fall short of the standard of care? Who knows? The attorneys will get paid to argue, but that's almost beside the point. Does any professional firm really want to defend its own errors one by one? Even if you win, you lose.

The design was produced using long-established professional practices. The contractor simply evaluated the engineer's final work product using a widely available analytical tool. The engineer didn't.

The engineer's capabilities hadn't diminished. What changed is the ability to discover, document, and litigate engineering deficiencies easily.

So the fuzziness around the Standard of Care that has made it a valuable refuge for cheap and mediocre engineering suddenly got a lot less fuzzy.

The Performance Bar for Engineers Has Moved Up

Whether your organization uses AI or not, clients, contractors, public interest groups, project opponents, and really anyone can now scrutinize and challenge your project management, cost estimating, scheduling, risk assessments, conclusions, thoroughness, and virtually every other measure of your firm's professional performance. Not just designs.

It's the same for public agencies. And not just work underway. Projects completed months or years ago can now be scrutinized using capabilities that weren't available when the work was performed.

Options and Actions

Delete all past project files - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - - just kidding.

Assume contractors will use AI to scrutinize your design documents to identify deficiencies, flag potential change orders, and support claims before bidding and during construction. Those who don't just haven't thought of it yet. It's sure to become SOP in 2027.

Consider implementing AI-assisted risk reviews immediately, prioritizing projects approaching construction or carrying significant technical and financial exposure.

Build intermittent AI-assisted quality reviews into your design process. Include it as a line item in the scope of work, and sell the efficiency, project cost savings, and risk reduction. Do the same for studies and reports. Challenge assumptions, identify omissions, examine interdisciplinary conflicts, and uncover inconsistencies while they're still easy and inexpensive to correct. Don't wait for somebody else to check your work. Use secure tools and qualified engineers to validate the findings.

Punchline: This is a good thing. When AI enables engineers to deliver better work with fewer errors, that value add is amplified throughout the project's life. Everyone wins, and that's the whole point.

Have a great weekend,

Dave

Feedback and blowback are welcome: dave@goodnewsfriday.com

All previous editions are available at goodnewsfriday.com

Good News Friday: Successful Engineering Consulting, hardback and Kindle, and now in paperback 😄